In article <1194093357.339037.268190@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>,
collection60@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
says...
> Within every question, there is a statement.
>
> Seeing as statements may be lies, therefor, questions may be lies.
>
> Seeing as statements may be abusive evil lies, therefor questions may
> be abusive evil lies.
>
> This is standard logic.
>
> For example, the question: "Why did the chicken cross the road", is
> stating that the chicken DID actually cross the road.
among other things.
other assumptions inherent to this question are : chickens exist, the
road exists, reality exists, movement and physical laws apply, time
applies, the chicken either have crossed the road or they havent, etc.
> What if the chicken did NOT cross the road,
and what if they did AND did not?
and what if they neither did nor didnt?
as you see, assumptions go way farther than you stated.
> yet this question was
> still asked? Then the question is false, or perhaps even a lying
> question.
>
> For example let's say Bush asks the question "Why did Sad-damn hide
> the WMDs". This is a lying question, because he is stating that
> Saddamn had WMDs to hide.
>
> Every question has within it, a statement. This is a hard, immutable
> fact.
"is your mom a whore?" is a good example to show that questions are not
necessarily harmless.
> And all statements may be turned into questions!
>
> Even the question "are you an asshole"... has a statement! The
> statement is "there is reason to believe that you may be an asshole".
>
> Now, this could be a lie. What if there is NO reason to believe that
> you are an asshole, yet someone asks "are you an asshole"?
>
> He may say that "well I wasn't really SAYING that you are an asshole,
> just asking a harmless question"... but it isn't harmless, because the
> question is stating that there is reasonable doubt, when in fact there
> was none.
>
> So even the question "are you X", can be an abusive lying question.
>
> This is basic, formal conclusive logic.
not very convinciong for a self-professed ultimate wizard.
--
Albert Einstein said, "No problem can be solved by the consciousness
that created it."
|
