http://newsweek.wa****ngtonpost.com/postglobal/kinming_liu/2008/05/chinas_fal=
l_from_grace_no_surp.html
China's Fall From Grace No Surprise
The Current Discussion: In his recent PostGlobal blog post, "The Ugly
Chinese," commentator John Pomfret says the world's perception of
China isn't as rosy as it used to be. Do you see China as a threat?
Why? Why not?
HONG KONG =96 Clear-eyed observers of China are a rare breed, but Steven
Mosher is one of them. In his brilliant 1991 book, China Misperceived:
American Illusions and Chinese Reality, Mosher wrote:
"For the past two centuries, American perceptions of China have
oscillated between the poles of love and hate. In brighter moments
China was seen as the land of Marco Polo and Pearl Buck, peopled with
wise, industrious, and courageous folk. But regularly, almost
cyclically, the pendulum swung back, and the cruel and violent China
of the Mongol hordes, the Boxer Rebellion, and the 'human wave'
attacks reasserted itself. The Chinese heroes of the anti-Japanese
resistance became the totalitarian m***** of the 1950s, the riotous
young rebels of the 1960s, the public-spirited proletarians of the
1970s, and the poor but deserving folk of the 1980s. The Tiananmen
massacre has once again tilted the balance, and the pendulum has swung
to the other dark extreme."
When the book came out in 1991, China's image had hit rock bottom. For
a while, it almost seemed the pendulum would never swing back to the
other direction. Who would have thought Beijing could pull off the
rebound that it did? And what an astoni****ng bounce back it was. A
decade after the Tiananmen massacre, China joined the World Trade
Organization, won the right to host the Olympics and became Wall
Street=92s darling. With the help from leading politicians, business
executives, scholars and diplomats in the West, China has successfully
implanted a rosy picture of its future in the world. Dubbed the
"Soothing Scenario" by James Mann in his book The China Fantasy: How
Our Leaders Explain Away Chinese Repression, it contends that the
successful spread of capitalism will inevitably lead to the
development of democratic institutions, free elections, an independent
judiciary and a progressive human rights policy. China is destined to
open up its political system, and trade is the key to unlocking the
door.
The Soothing Scenario looked like it was all set to bloom this summer,
when a supposedly peaceful-rising China was scheduled to have a coming-
out party at the Olympics. Then, out of the blue, the plan was
derailed. The Ugly Chinaman took the stage. The pendulum is once again
swinging, and fast. It's really extraordinary for knee-jerk anti-
American Europeans to view the Middle Kingdom as more dangerous than
the Great Satan. In fact, it should have come as no surprise to anyone
who sees through to the real nature of the regime, which has remained
unchanged despite spectacular developments on the surface of Chinese
society. The Chinese Communist Party is interested in only one thing:
holding on to power. It has only two tools with which to do so: more
lies and more repression.
After the Tiananmen massacre, the eminent China scholar Simon Ley=92s
*****sment was, I believe, still valid for China today:
"Unfortunately, its poison might outlast the beast itself. The legacy
of such a regime can even be more evil than its rule. The collapse of
the present government is ineluctable; what is to be feared is that,
after 40 years of economic mismanagement, in the present cir***stances
of overpopulation and poverty, with a population brutalized by four
decades of relentless political terror, worse horrors may
follow." (After the Massacres The New York Review of Books, October
12, 1989)
Brainwashed by the regime and ignorant of the bloody history of the
People's Republic since 1949, the new generation of angry youths
smacks of the Red Guards during the Cultural Revolution.
Michael A. Ledeen, a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute,
points to a likely chilling future of China. In an article, "Beijing
Embraces Classical Fascism" in the latest issue of the Far Eastern
Economic Review, Mr. Ledeen argues that the heirs to Mao Tsetung and
Deng Xiaoping act more like disciples of Mussolini and Hitler than
communists. "Hitler's Germany and Mussolini's Italy were every bit as
sensitive to any sign of foreign criticism as the Chinese today, both
because victimhood is always part of the definition of such states,
and because it's an essential technique of mass control," Mr. Ledeen
writes. Like their European predecessors, the Chinese claim a major
role in the world because of their history and culture, not just on
the basis of their current power, or their scientific or cultural
accomplishments. "It is only a matter of time before China will pursue
confrontation with the West," predicts Mr. Ledeen. "A great Roman once
said that if you want peace, prepare for war."
Beijing 2008 has always reminded me of Berlin 1936. I'm not the only
one who feels that way. Some Jewish leaders in the U.S. are calling
for the boycott of the Olympics. In a petition called "China Olympics
Are Not Kosher", they say:
"We remember all too well that the road to Nazi genocide began in the
1930s, with Hitler's efforts to improve the public image of his evil
regime. Nazi Germany sought to attract visitors to the 1936 Olympics
in order to distract attention from its persecution of the Jews.
Hitler's propaganda minister, Joseph Goebbels, called the 1936 games
'a victory for the German cause.' We dare not permit today's
totalitarian regimes to achieve such victories."
I can only pray that the West will find another Churchill and
Roosevelt.
|
