e -Voice Of Human Rights Watch - e-news weekly
Spreading the light of humanity & freedom
Editor: Nagaraj.M.R....vol.4...issue.12......21/03/2008
<a href="http://www.amnesty.org"><img
border="0" alt="Sup****t Amnesty
International" title="Sup****t Amnesty International" src="http://
www.amnesty.org/images/banners/banner2-red/banner2-468x60-eng.jpg"/></a>
Editorial : Failure of RTI Act in India
- In the clutches of corrupt public servants mafia
In the courts of law , every statement to be valid must be sup****ted
by evidences. That too, the statements of public servants / government
officials & their re****ts in government records are considered as
sacrosanct , the ultimate gospel truth by courts of law.
The corruption has spread it's tentacles far & wide in the public
service. The bribe booty is shared by lower to higher officials. If an
official is complained against , his higher official conducts a formal
investigation & re****ts in the record that lower official is not
guilty.
The vigilance authorities / Karnataka lokayukta has recently raided on
police , tax officials & seized illegal wealth amounting to crores of
rupees. Take the recent case where in senior IPS officer ,
superintendent of police chamarajanagar , mr.srikantappa was arrested
by Karnataka lokayukta. The victims spoke to media that he used to
threaten them with false cases. In this way , how many victims /
innocents were arrested & tortured by his arrest warrants ? how many
innocents suffered in false cases ? how many rich criminals got scot
free , by srikantappa's filing of B re****ts leading to closure of
cases ?
In the past how many suffered by srikantappa's actions ? has the court
subjected to review all the previous actions of srikantappa throught
his corrupt career ? if not , why ?
The courts of law has taken the official re****ts , records of
mr.srikantappa as gospel truth & indirectly aided rich criminals &
harmed innocents. It is the same case with respect to re****ts of all
government officials - police , labour , tax , etc. the rich
criminals buy out government officials & make them write favourable
re****t about themselves. Whereas the poor , innocents suffer from
adverse re****ts & injustices. The courts of law takes the government
records at it's face value & meat out injustices to the poor ,
innocents while aiding the rich criminals.
When a commoner requests for information as per RTI Act , the
government officials either give incomplete information , false
information or decline to give information under one pretext or the
other. The officials are damn sure that the truthful information will
be detrimental to themselves & will be taken as evidence against
themselves in the courts of law. So information , truth is not given.
Even information commissions are failing here. Thereby, the public are
denied to seek justice in the courts of law , by lack of evidences.
The courts of law before accepting the records of government
officials , must subject it to a "test of truth". When a government
re****t is contested against , a fact finding team comprising members
of public , complainant , respondent & the court , must check it out
at the ground level. Orelse when a complainant says that the re****t of
a government official - police , labour , tax , etc as false that
government official must be subjected to lie detector test , narco-
analysis, ertc by court of law. The questionnaire ie the questions to
be asked during the scientific test are to be prepared with feedback
from both complainant & respondent's side. In that way , impartially
truth can be found out. After all , the objective of courts of law is
"Quest for Truth", not just giving out judgements based on re****ts of
corrupt officials.
Nowadays , we are even seeing re****ts of corruption among the
judiciary itself. If a complaint against a judge is made out that a
level ground is not provided to put up one's case in the court or
cross examination of one party is not allowed or lie detector test /
narco analysis of one party is not allowed ( in turn taking the lies
of that party as truth ), the judge making a varied interpretation of
law, the judge not safe guarding the health & life of the complainant
in the custody of police leading to 3rd degree torture of complainant
by police , etc, in all such cases the supreme court of India must
change the presiding judge of such cases , the cases must be
thoroughly reviewed & the guilty judge must be subjected to narco-
analysis , lie detector test , etc & legally prosecuted. In this back
drop , accountability of police & judges to the public ie citizens of
India - kings of democracy , is a must. After all , the kings of
democracy / citizens of India / taxpayers are the paymasters of all
public servants.
We at e - voice of human rights of watch have utmost respect for the
judiciary & all government institutions. It is the corrupt few in
those institutions who are themselves bringing disgrace to the august
institutions they occupy , by their corrupt deeds. The saving grace is
that still honest few are left in public service & it is an appeal to
them , to legally prosecute their corrupt colleagues.
In India , the private enterprises are the wealth creators of our
economy. However , some private enterprises are violating labour
laws , tax laws , human rights & fundamental rights of people. In turn
harming the public , looting the tax dues. This is creating black
money causing various social evils in the society. These huge private
enterprises take loans from public sector banks ie take public's money
as loans , collect money from public in the form of shares ,
debentures , sell their product to the public. Still , they are not
covered by RTI Act, they don't give truthful information to the public
nor allow public inspection of their sites , why ? they buy out
concerned government officials & gets them to write favourable re****t
about themselves. There are wide differences between the ground
reality & these government re****ts. If the aggrieved person , victim
of injustices meated out by these private enterprises , tries to
legally seek justice, these criminal private enterprises buy out
police , concerned officials & fixes up the victim in false cases. The
police in total disregard to law violates the human rights &
fundamental rights of the victim in custody , subjects the victim to
3rd degree torture in custody. The presiding judge of the case doesn't
safe guard the rights , health , life of victims in custody. The judge
doesn't check out the truthfulness of government re****ts & p***** on
judgement making varied interpretation of just remember the case of
"local citizens vs coca cola company" in plachimada , kerala.
Is it not right & just in such cases , to subject the presiding
judge , police , concerned government officialds & most im****tantly
key officials of that criminal private enterprise to lie detector ,
narco- analysis tests , to know the truth ? is it not right to conduct
the inspection of alleged site , review of all company's records , by
a team comprising of members from public , court , complainant &
respondent ?
Some of these criminal enterprises threaten to finish off the poor
victims . as these company's have money power they can buy out
rowdies , police & capable of doing anything. In such cases , if
anything untoward happens to the victim or his family , are not the
officials of such criminal enterprise liable to pay compensation to
the victims's family or survivors ?
In India , do we truly have democracy & freedom ? is this corrupt
India - what our freedom fighters dreamt of & fought for ? JAI HIND.
VANDE MATARM.
Your's sincerely,
Nagaraj.M.R.
Raid by Karnataka lokayukta on police officials
- seizure of crores worth illegal wealth
KINDLY REVIEW ALL THE PREVIOUS OFFICIAL ACTIONS OF THESE CORRUPT
OFFICIALS AS THERE ARE EVERY POSSIBILITY OF INNOCENTS SUFFERRING
INJUSTICES & RICH CRIMINALS GOING SCOT FREE.
in our neighbourhood , in our society private sector employees earning
rs.10000 monthly income are finding it hard to meet ends , whereas
many of the government officials earning lesser salary than that are
leading luxurious lifestyles , how ?
Just yesterday Karnataka lokayukta raided & apprehended high police
officials for possessing crores worth illegal wealth much above their
stated legal incomes.
recently in the last week Karnataka lokayukta raided , seized illegal
wealth of corrupt police , trans****t officials. The corruption is wide
spread in public service including Karnataka lokayukta , central
vigilance commission & CBI itselves. In 2006, when Karnataka lokayukta
arrested 5 corrupt police officials & taking them in police jeep , 2
corrupt police officials escaped like petty criminals in cinematic
manner.
There are vast number of corrupt public servants who are continuing
their crimes unabetted due to their sharing arrangements with their
higher ups. Only a minute number of corrupt are being booked, by the
efforts of honest few in Karnataka lokayukta , CVC & CBI . The paradox
is that the government instead of legally prosecuting those criminals
- corrupt officials , is sitting over their files for years & have
reinstated , promoted tainted officials.
Why do rich people / criminals pay bribe to police ? definitely not
for charity , but not to mention their names in the FIR , to let them
continue their crimes unabetted , to suppress evidences / witnesses ,
not to make their arrests , to conduct improper investigations , to
close a case with B re****t , not to produce evidences / witnesses
before the court , to fix-up poor innocents , to force the poor
innocents to do the bidding of rich criminals , etc .
As a result of these sell out of police duties , rich criminals are
going scot free , poor innocents are suffering in jail & corrupt
police are amassing illegal wealth.
In the same way corrupt health department officials / doctors are
selling out post mortem re****ts , medical certificates for a price ,
giving out certificates of legal compliance to adulterated food /
medicine manufacturers , thereby killing thousands of people in their
selfish greed to make more money.
The labour / pollution control board officials are selling out
certificates , to criminal industrialists who are indulging in unfair
labour practices , occupational hazards , thereby killing poor
people , in their greed to make a fortune.
The tax officials are making lesser / favourable tax *****sments
favouring industrialists /traders for a price, aiding them to evade
tax. As a result the public exchequer is loosing money , for it's
social welfare , defence , other programmes. The ill-gotten wealth of
industrialists / traders ie BLACK MONEY is disturbing our national
economy & finding it's way to underworld , mafia & terrorist outfits.
The corrupt police , tax officials , public servants are worse
parasites than britishers . the threat & damge to india's security ,
integrity is more from these criminals - corrupt public servants than
from USA , CHINA or PAKISTAN.
False Affidavits , Information Hiding - Crimes of supreme court of
India & Public Servants
Many public servants are leading luxurious lifestyles , beyond the
legal sources of their income. Many public servants are filing false
affidavits about their annual income , wealth details to Election
Commission of India / Vigilance Commission / other authorities , as
the case may be. These authorities are not properly verifying these
affidavits . many scams , scandals are coming to light day in & day
out , politicians are accussing each other of involvement in scams.
Whereas , the said authorities are keeping mum , as if those
affidavits filed by tainted public servants are true.
The tainted public servants are not even providing full , right
information to public as per RTI Act, lest the truth come out. Just
imagine , even the supreme court of India violated RTI Act - failed to
give information to our publication as per RTI Act , lest the truth -
skeletons in judiciary comes out.
Some public servants , caught redhanded during luxurious spending ,
easily says that it is at their political paty's expense or their well
wisher's expense. However no entries are found in the account books of
said parties to that respect. The law forbids public servants from
accepting gifts , hospitality , favours beyond the value of rupees one
hundred ( Rs. 100 ) , as it may be a form of bribe.
Hereby , HRW urges the honourable supreme court of India , to enforce
RTI Act , annual filing of affidavits by public servants , fool-proof
verification of those affidavits by public committees comprising
ordinary citizens as mandatory encompassing all public offices. As a
first step , it must be enforced to judges , police personnel & tax
officials . then alone , many socio-economic problems , corruption in
India can be solved.
AN APPEAL TO HONOURABLE KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA , CENTAL VIGILANCE
COMMISSIONER & DIRECTOR CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Hereby , we do call upon Karnataka lokayukta , central vigilance
commission & CBI
1. To stop accepting all government officials re****ts , re****ts as
sacrosanct do***ents , most truthful evidences.
2. to publish wealth details of it's own staff & all public servants
department wise annually with provision for cross verification by
public.
3. to make it mandatory for all public servants including judges ,
constitutional functionaries to submit annual wealth statements on
affidavit & to make it public with provision for cross verification by
public.
4. to initiate legal action for those giving false statements on
affidavit.
5. the corrupt public servants who intentionally give false
information or hide information under one pretext or the other while
information is sought under RTI Act , all with a view to hide crimes
must be legally prosecuted as criminals as in normal legal recourse
persons who help criminals in destroying evidences , crimes are
prosecuted.
6. the corrupt officials don't leave evidences in open. Their higher
ups who have taken kick backs from their corrupt subordinate always
give a favourable re****t about him. So, during legal prosecution those
re****ts must not be relied upon. In fact , there is a gross mismatch
between government re****ts & ground reality. Take for example , in
mysore construction is going on in INFOSYS campus on huge scale . most
of the construction workers are not even covered by statuotary
requirement of ESI , PF. The occupational hazards are more ,
accidents are common place , recently even deaths of workers have
occurred due to occupational hazards . in the media also it was
re****ted , in the media re****t it was even mentioned that vijayanagar
police have registered a case & investigating. However when the
information about it was sought from labour commissioner of Karnataka
as per RTI Act , assistant labour commissioner of mysore has stated
that no occupational deaths have taken place in either 2006 or 2007.
SEE THE GROUND REALITY IS DIFFERENT WHEREAS THE GOVERNMENT RECORD ,
LABOUR DEPARTMENT RECORDS SING A DIFFERENT TUNE. THE FAILURE IN OUR
DEMOCRACY IS THAT THESE FAKE RECORDS , STATEMENTS OF GOVERNMENT
OFFICIALS ARE TAKEN AS ULTIMATE TRUTH BY COURTS OF LAW & PROSECUTING
AUTHORITIES. I can give more actual examples like this.
7. so , involve public in the inspection teams , raiding parties of
tax department , labour department , excise department , drugs
control , weights & measures , etc. these public can put a check to
the corrupt practices , fake records of these corrupt government
officials.
8. kindly do remember that in 2006-07 , a corrupt judge was exposed
by media efforts. The said corrupt judge in his urgency to collect
bribe has not even looked at the INTENDED PERSONS TO BE ARRESTED &
blindly signed the copies of arrest warrant . the arrest warrant was
against H.E . PRESIDENT OF INDIA , HONOURABLE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA &
HONOURABLE PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA. As in the normal working of
government machinery if it was pursued , president of India , chief
justice of India & prime minister of India should have been arrested.
Technically speaking it was right. However common sense prevailed &
the higher judiciary took appropriate action as the issue concerned
VVIPs. Normally our courts of law , authorities work without common
sense like horses of horse cart whose eyes are partially covered
allowing only narrow vision , just by relying on government re****ts ,
records of corrupt public servants. The courts , authorities just
functions by technicalities. This must stop for the sake of justice ,
fairness.
9. when a public makes complaint to Karnataka lokayukta , CVC or CBI
about corrupt practices of a public servant , they must stop relying
on the legal opinion of it's own advocates as they just rely on
government records. Take for example the wrong legal opinion of legal
expert of Karnataka lokayukta. The lokayukta has legal jurisdiction to
inquire into all Karnataka state government institutions &
organizations funded , sup****ted by government of Karnataka. There
are other examples where In Karnataka lokayukta has taken action
against employees of Karnataka government aided institutions . The PES
COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING mandya is funded & aided by government of
Karnataka , but when we made a complaint regarding corruption in that
institution , the legal expert of Karnataka lokayukta gave his expert
opinion that the said institution is out of lokayukta's legal
jurisdiction , so no action is called for . based on this opinion
Karnataka lokayukta rejected my complaint. Some of these legal experts
are indirectly covering up criminals , stop relying on their expert
opinions.
10. when a complaint is given to Karnataka lokayukta , CVC or CBI
they in turn ask the complainant himself for sup****ting evidences ,
records. The government has given them vast police force to enforce
law , to inquire & to collect evidences. How can a commoner can
collect evidences , the criminal don't leave evidences in open , all
the commoner can do is make complaint regarding the injustices he has
suffered. The complaints must be accepted & inquired into with or
without evidences , lack of evidences should not be the sole reason
for dismissal of complaint as presently Karnataka lokayukta , CVC &
CBI are doing .
11. review all the past official decisions of corrupt officials
apprehended by Karnataka lokayukta , CVC & CBI. As there are
possibilities of innocents suffering injustices & rich criminals
going scot free.
AN APPEAL TO HONOURABLE CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSIONER , NEW DELHI &
STATE INFOR MATION COMMISSIONER , BANGALORE.
We at e-voice of human rights watch has requested for following
information ( ANSWERS TO THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS ) from honourable
supreme court of India , union home ministry & director general of
police for Karnataka , as per RTI Act . All the three have failed to
provide complete truthful information to us. Hereby , we do once
again request you to order the said three - supreme court of India ,
union home ministry GOI & DGP of Karnataka , to comply with RTI Act &
to provide the full information us at the earliest.
CROSS-EXAMINATION OF HONOURABLE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA , UNION HOME
MINISTER & DGP OF KARNATAKA
Q1. Why not death sentence to corrupt police who murder people in in
lock-up / fake encounters ?
Q2. Why not death sentence to corrupt police who apply 3rd degree
torture on prisoners ?
Q3. Why not death sentence to corrupt police , who connive with
criminals & backstabs our motherland , it's national security ?
Q4. Don't the police have suo-motto powers to take action in the
interest of public welfare , law & order ?
Q5. Daily we see numerous re****ts of misdeeds by police , public
servants , industrialists , etc in the media . Then why not police
taking any action with respect to them ?
Q6. nowadays we see numerous re****ts of scams , scandals by
constitutional functionaries , public servants in the media. Instead
of wasting money , killing time by prolonging formation of
parliamentary committees , judicial commissions , why not subject
those accussed public servants to narco analysis , lie deector test ,
etc to ascertain truth & provide timely justice ? ( new addition )
Q7. If a commonman files a complaint , police / courts wants
evidences , witnesses to take action against the rich & mighty crooks.
Where as if a rich person just gives a complaint against a poor chap ,
he is arrested , tortured eventhough there are no evidences ,
witnesses. Why this double standard ?
Q8. If a poor chap tries to collect evidences as per his fundamental
rights or as per RTI ACT , the public servants don't give full ,
truthfull information. Still , police / courts don't take action
against those public servants hiding crimes. Why ?
Q9.why I was not permitted to appear as an "amicus curie" before jain
commission of enquiry or supreme court of india probing late prime
minister rajiv Gandhi assassination case ?
Q10. The criminal nexus tried to silence me , by closing my news
paper , by snatching away my job oppurtunities in government service,
by physically assaulting me , by threatening me of false fix-ups in
cases & by attempts to murder me. But no action against culprits ,
why ?
Q11. Whereas , I was enquired number of times by police & intelligence
personnel about this case , but the culprits were not enquired even
once , why ?
Q12.who compensates the losses I have suffered due to these
injustices ? are not police responsible for it ?
Q13. Is it not the duty of police to protect the lives , livelihood of
witnesses & all parties involved , both during case & afterwards ?
Q14. How do you monitor & check corrupt police personnel & increase in
their family's wealth year after year ?
Q15. While getting appointed into government service from the rank of
peon to IAS officer , police verification is mandatory. While
appointing to sensitive defense establishments , research institutes
in addition to police verification , central intelligence agencies
cross-check candidate's background. However is there no background
checks of constitutional functionaries , MPs , MLAs , , who are privy
to national secrets ? why ?
Q16. Recently , the opposition parties have made allegations during
presidential allegations that close relative of one of the front
running candidates have swindled public money by their bank , misused
public money through one of their NGO. Is it true ?
Q17.has GOI funded any terrorist outfits in india or abroad ?
Q18.india preaches non-violence , panchasheel principles to the world.
In india , more than half the population are poor , people are
starving to death. Inspite these background , GOI funded & aided
terrorist outfits in former east Pakistan ensuring the creation of
Bangladesh , GOI has funded & aided terrorist outfits like LTTE ,
TULF , ETC in srilanka , MQM in Pakistan. In turn these terrorist
outfits have murdered thousands of innocents in those countries. Are
these acts of GOI just & legal ? Is not GOI responsible for all those
murders of innocents ? has GOI paid any compensation to those victims
or their family mebers ? why not ?
Q19.within india , to reduce the influence of certain terrorist
groups , GOI has funded & aided couter terrorist groups , is it right
& legal ?
Q20. In Jharkhand , chattisgarh , etc , the government has armed ,
trained & funded "salwa judum" to counter naxalites. Salwa judum
cadres are terrorizing innocents just like naxalites. Is this action
of government just & legal ?
Q21.in india, TADA , POTA is being rampantly misused by police. Even
where there are no problems of terrorism , TADA / POTA is being
slapped against innocents , even children. In M.M.Hills of Karnataka
state , STF personnel charged tribal people with TADA on frivolous
charges of taking lunch to veerappan , stiching dress for the forest
brigand, etc. where as the prominent political, film , s****ts
personalities who have links with underworld , anti national elements
& attended parties hosted by dawood Ibrahim , other dons in gulf
countries , else where. But these hi-fi people are not charged with
TADA / POTA ? why ?
Q22. Film actor sanjay dutt had contacts with underworld & fully
knowing well the criminal objectives of criminals , hid the dangerous
arms & ammunition in his home , which were intended for terrorizing
public. However mr.dutt is not charged with TADA / POTA instead he is
charged with illegal possession of arms act ( which is normally
applied to farmers who use illegal home made guns to scare away
animals , birds in their farms ). Why this favourable treatment of
mr.dutt by police ? prosecution ? is this because dutt is politically
mighty & rich ?
Q23. Law is one & same for all , the public servants, police
interpretes , enforces it differentially between rich & poor ? why
this differentiation ?
Q24.recently in Bangalore police nabbed criminals belonging to
international criminal syndicate selling duplicate nokia mobiles.
Every nokia mobile comes with 15 digit IMEI number , this number is
also used by police for tracking criminals. In consumer dispute at
consumer disputes redressal forum Mysore CD 49/05 , nokia company
stated that all it's products come with IMEI number only & stated that
the product in dispute sold by tata indicom dealer M/S INTOTO
COMMUNICATIONS , Mysore are not their's as it doesn't have IMEI
numbers. Further nokia stated they don't have any business
relation****p with either tata indicom or it's dealer. However the tata
indicom dealer stated that indeed his products are genuine , first
hand products , but doesn't have IMEI numbers . this proves the dealer
in collusion with tata company is selling illegal nokia mobile hand
sets & cheating the public. These mobiles are evading taxes , as well
as these are without IMEI numbers best buy for criminal elements who
want to evade police tracking. What police are doing ?
Q25. Who , of which rank among police personnel takes the decision to
close a case ie to file "B" re****t , when after certain time limit no
leads are found in investigation ?
Q26. How do you monitor corrupt police personnel , who purposefully
fail to investigate case properly , so that either the case can be
closed with "B" re****t or the prosecution fails to prove the case in
court ?
Q27. Who among police takes the decision to appeal against the verdict
of a lower court , when the prosecution fails ?
Q28. Who took the decision , not to appeal against the argentina court
order acquitting mr.quatrochi accussed in bofors scandal ?
Q29. Do you treat all the prison convicts same in the prison or does
the notorious big time rich criminals get spacious barracks with tv,
news paper , adequate food , medical care , etc while small time
criminals , poor are crammed into pig sty like rooms with 60-70
inmates without any basic requirements ?
Q30. What is the status of my complaint made to the DG & IG of
police , government of Karnataka on 10/12/2004 ? the copies of
complaint was released at press meet at patrakartara bhavan Mysore on
same day, even copies were given to police & intelligence personnel ?
Q31. Why no action , reply regarding the complaint till date ?
Q32. Our constitutional frame workers gave legal immunity privileges
to certain constitutional functionaries , so that they are not
burdened with frivolous court cases & can concentrate on their
constitutional duties. But these privileges doesn't cover the
individual actions of those public servants like rape , murder , dowry
harassment , tax evasion , misuse of office , etc. but still law
enforcement / police department is bound to send request to home
ministry seeking permission & home ministry sits over files for
months. This gives the accussed ample time to destroy evidences. Is it
right & legal ?
Q33. Does legal immunity privileges cover their official actions
alone ? if not what does it cover ?
Q34. What is the time limit for home ministry to give sanction for the
prosecution of tainted constitutional functionaries ?
Q35. How many present MPs , MLAs , MUNICIAPAL COR****ATORS , other
people's representatives are facing criminal charges ?
Q36. In the past , how many MPs , MLAs , cor****ators were facing
criminal charges , yearwise since 1987 ? how many of them were
eventually convicted ?
Q37. How many MPs , MLAs , prominent film , s****ts personalities have
have contacts with underworld , foreign intelligence agencies ?
Q38. How many of them have attended frequent parties hosted by
underworld dons in gulf countries , else where ?
Q39. How many MP , MLA , other people's representatives are
wanted by police in various cases . but shown in the police records as
absconding but in reality are attending the proceedings of the house
as usual ?
Q40. When did smt. Sonia Gandhi became a citizen of india ? did she
occupy any public office before naturalization ?
Q41. In india , how many MPs , MLAs , MLCs are of foreign origin or
have a spouse of foreign origin ?
Q42. Does smt. Sonia Gandhi have citizen****p of any other country ?
Q43. Did she occupy any public office while enjoying dual
citizen****p ?
Q44. How do you monitor public servants who have spouses of foreign
origin & while they are on foreign tour , from national security
perspective ?
Q45. Is mr. M.S SUBBA member of parliament a citizen of india ?
Q46. What is the status of complaint made by former union minister
mr.subramanya swamy alleging that late P.Mrajiv gandhi's family
received money from foreign intelligence agencies ?
Q47. In many cases like mass riots involving certain political
parties , when that culprit party comes to power all the cases
involving it's partymen are withdrawn by the government orelse
prosecution fails to prove it's case & prefers not to appeal. Just
remember Bombay riot case involving ****v sainiks & others , when ****v
sena - BJP came to power in Maharashtra , all the cases against it's
partymen were withdrawn. Are these type of decisions by government
just & legal ?
Q48.what damages has been done to india's national security due to
mole in the PMO, as alleged by former union minister mr.natwar singh ?
Q49. What action by the government ?
Q50. How many Indians are in the custody of police / military in
various foreign countries ?
Q51. How many foreigners are there in Indian prisons ?
Q52. How GOI is protecting the human rights of these prisoners ?
Q53. Is the government paying any compensation to victims of police
failures , fix-ups , , who suffer in jail for years & acquitted by
courts upon finding them as not guilty ?
Q54. Do you register murder charges / attempt to murder charges
against guilty police officers who are responsible for lock-up
deaths , fake encounters & 3rd degree torture ?
Q55. How many cases has been filed since 1987 till date ?
Q56. What action has been taken against guilty police officers , STF
personnel who were responsible for gross human rights violations , 3rd
degree torture , lock-up deaths of innocents in forest brigand
veerappan's territory , based on justice A.J.Sada****va commission
findings ? if not why ?
Q57. I , as a citizen of india as my "fundamental duty" hereby do
offer my conditional services to GOI & GOK to apprehend corrupt public
servants. Are you ready to utilize my services ?
Q58. Police personnel are always in the forefront of containing
crimes , mass fury , riots , etc. they suffer more & even their family
members suffer threats from the criminal elements. Do the government
provide insurance coverage to police & their family members on the
lines of defense forces ?
Q59. What is the amount of coverage to a police constable & his
family ?
Q60. Who makes the premium contributions ?
Q61. Do the government provide overtime allowance , food allowance to
police who daily work beyond 8 hours of duty ?
Q62. Is the government giving any training to police personnel in
public interaction , human rights ?
Q63. Is it right to post professionally trained police to sentry ,
orderly duties of ministers ?
Q64. What is the ratio of police personnel to total population in
india since 1987 ?
Q65. IS THE GOVERNMENT GIVING ADEQUATE FOOD, MEDICAL CARE , CLOTHING ,
LIVING SPACE TO PRISON INMATES , AS REQUIRED BY A NORMAL HUMAN EING
ACCORDING TO W.H.O NORMS ?
Q66. Is the forensic science department which conducts narcfo-
analysis , lie-detector test , etc under the control of police
department ?
Q67. Is it not right to put it under impartial control of NHRC or like
bodies ?
Q68. Is the action of some police officers arranging compromise
meetings & subtly insisting the poor to tow the line of rich or else
face the consequences , is it right & legal ? this happens mostly in
real estate matters.
Q69. Did government make any ransom payments to forest brigand
veerappan during his various kidnappings ?
Q70. What action has been taken based on revealations by karim telgi
during narco analysis about public servants involvement ?
Q71. How many cases of allegations against judges were made in the
media about misuse of office , criminal acts by judges from munsiff
court to supreme court of India ? since 1947 till date
Q72. are the enquiry re****t findings, action taken re****ts of such
cases accessible to public ? if not why ?
Q73. what action has been taken against guilty judges ?
Q74. are the guilty judges legally prosecuted in all such cases ? or
has it just ended with their resignation from services or his superior
judge not allotting him any judicial work ?
Q75. why some high ranking judges are not legally prosecuted for their
wrong doings ?
Q76. are judges above law ? are not everybody equal before law ?
Q77. do the judiciary subject , all the cases handled by accussed /
tainted , guilty judges to review , to undo past unjust judgements ?
Q78. how ? if not why ?
Q79. how do the judiciary monitor the net wealth growth of some
judges including the wealth in the name of judge's family members ?
Q80. do all the judges file their annual income , wealth statements on
sworn affidavits to the higher judiciary ? defaulters how many ?
Q81. how does the judiciary verifies those statements ?
Q82. is such statements made public , on web ?
Q83. when the judgement of a lower court is turned down by the higher
court , what action is initiated against lower court judge for making
unjust judgement & meating out injustice ?
Q84. when allegations of corruption , misuse of office , etc against
judges are made , why the accussed - judges are not subjected to
tests like "poly graph , lie detector , brain mapping , etc" , in the
interest of justice & truth ?
Q85. judges are not employees of government , so they are ineligible
to be the members of "Karnataka state government judicial department
house building co-operative society". Then how come , many judges
including supreme court judges are admitted as members of this society
& allotted prime residential site worth crores of rupees for a few
thousands by the said society at said society's - judicial layout ,
yelahanka , Bangalore ? while the ordinary members like peons , clerks
in judicial department are waiting for a site since years , is not the
whole thing grossly illegal ?
Q86. in more than 70% of cases before all courts in India , central
government or state government or government agency is one of the
parties. How many judges or their family members , have received out
of turn , favourable allotments of sites , gas agency , petrol pumps ,
etc by the government ? is not such allotments illegal ? what action ?
Q87. when a person under police custody or judicial custody suffer 3rd
degree torture by police , is not the judge of the respective court
which is handling that tortured person's case responsible for it ?
Q88. has the higher judiciary legally prosecuted respective judges &
the police officers for committing 3rd degree torture , on charges of
attempt to murder & murder ? if not why ?
Q89. registrar , Mysore district & sessions court , has called for the
candidatures to various vacancies in that court from the public vide
notification no : ADMN/A/10825/2003 dated 19/11/2003 & collected
application fees from the candidates. Till may 2007 , they have not
even conducted the interview ? is it not public cheating by
judiciary ? what action to undo the injustices to unemployed ?
Q90. registrar , Bangalore city civil court , has called for the
candidatures to various vacancies in that court from the public vide
notification no : ADM-I(A)422/03 dated 19/05/2003 & collected
application fees from the candidates. Till date , they have not even
conducted the interview ? is it not public cheating by the judiciary ?
what action to undo injustices to unemployed ?
Q91. when a person doesn't get adequate food , medical care while
under police custody or judicial custody , is not the respective judge
dealing that person's case responsible for it ? what action ?
Q92. how judiciary is monitoring food & medical care to prisoners ?
Q93. numerous accussed persons are suffering in jail under judicial
custody , for periods far exceeding the legally stipulated sentence
periods. For example : a pick-pocketer is in jail for one year , the
judge finds him guilty of offence & gives him 3 months sentence. What
about the excess punishment of 9 months. Is not the judge responsible
for the illegal , excess punishment of the convict ? what action
against the judge in such cases ?
Q94. numerous innocents suffer in jail for years & finally the judge
finds them as innocents & acquits them of the charges. What about the
prison sentence , the innocent has already served ? is not the judge
responsible for this illegal , unjust punishment to an innocent ?
remedy ? what action against the judge ?
Q95. does the privileges of judges cover both their official actions &
the actions arising out of misuse of office ?
Q96. does the privileges of judges cover both their official actions
as judges & their personal actions as individuals ?
Q97. are the fundamental rights of citizens supreme or the privileges
of judges , constitutional functionaries supreme ?
Q98. what is the criteria adopted for promotion of judges ?
Q99. what is the criteria adopted for appointment of advocates from
bar , as the judges ?
Q100. what is the criteria adopted for appointment of retired judges ,
as governors of states , members or as chairman of commissions ,
etc ?
Q101. how many judges belonging to oppressed cl***** - scheduled
caste , scheduled tribe , other backward cl***** , minorities & women
are their in supreme court , state high courts & subordinate courts ?
kindly provide specific figures .
Q102. what are the legal measures enforced by judiciary , to enforce
the accountability of judges & to check corruption in judiciary ?
Q103. are not these measures a failure , looking at present state of
affairs of judiciary ?
Q104. does the judges arrange for distribution of alchoholic drinks at
the official meetings , parties , at the tax payer's expense ?
Q105. does any judges have included their consumption of alchoholic
drinks , in their hotel bill & claimed traveling allowance ?
Q106. what action has been taken against - selectors ie Karnataka high
court judges & newly selected women judges involved in roost resort
scandal in Mysore , Karnataka ?
Q107. when common people / tax payers & even government employees are
not getting proper health care from government at government
hospitals. Is it right & just to provide premium health care to
judges , constitutional functionaries at 5-star private hospitals in
India , abroad , all at tax payer's expense ?
Q108. are the judges subjected to periodical health check-ups to
ascertain their health , mental faculties & mental balance in the
midst of all work pressures , emotional tensions ?
Q109. what is the criteria adopted by judiciary for accepting
applications seeking public interest litigations ?
Q110. why numerous appeals for PIL by me , were not considered ?
Q111. what is the criteria adopted by judiciary , for appointing
"amicus curie" in a case ?
Q112. why my appeal to honourable supreme court , to make me as an
"amicus curie" in late P.M Rajiv Gandhi's assassination case , was not
considered by the court ?
Q113. what is the criteria adopted by judiciary , for initiating suo-
motto action ?
Q114. numerous cases of injustices are re****ted in the media daily ,
with sup****ting evidences . why not the judiciary take suo-motto
action in all such cases ?
Q115. legal aid boards pre-judge the cases in the name of taking legal
opinion , before providing legal aid to the needy ? is it not needy
person's rights violation ?
Q116. is not the safety of witnesses , parties in cases responsibility
of the court , both during hearing of the case & afterwards ?
Q117. is the use of 3rd degree torture by police on prisoners ,
during the police custody / judicial custody / prison sentence
right ? what action ?
Q118. when the corrupt police officer & government prosecution
advocate together cover-up evidences , conducts improper investigation
intentionally to fail the case - to cover-up rich crooks , high &
mighty people , what action judge takes in such cases ?
Q119. how does the judiciary monitor the wealth growth of police ,
government advoctes , tax officials , officials of licensing
authorities , to ensure proper & fair prosecution of cases against
rich & mighty ?
Q120. what are the status of appeals made by human rights activist
NAGARAJ.M.R. to the honourable supreme court of India ?
Q121. corruption is rampant for selection of officers to quasi-
judicial positions like district / taluk magistrates , tax officers ,
revenue officers , land acquisition officers , etc. how the judiciary
monitors over their quasi-judicial actions ?
Q122. subject to conditions , I , NAGARAJ.M.R. , editor , e-voice of
human rights watch , do offer my free services to honourable supreme
court of India , to apprehend corrupt judges , are you - the
honourable court ready to utilize it ?
Q123. what are the status of my appeals , sent to the honourable
supreme court of India , through government of india's on-line
grievance system ( DPG & DARPG ) :
DPG/M/2006/80008 , DARPG/E/2006/00057, DARPG/E/2006/00225 , DPG/M/
2006/80021 , DARPG/E/2006/00253 , DPG/M/2006/80032 , DARPG/E/
2006/01149 , DPG/M/2006/80047 , DARPG/E/2006/01164 , DPG/M/
2006/80043 , DPG/M/2006/80085 , DARPG/E/2006/06704 , DARPG/E/
2006/07017 , DARPG/E/2006/07018 , DPG/M/2006/80159 , DPG/M/
2006/80162 , DARPG/E/2006/07864 , DPG/M/2006/80165 , DARPG/E/
2006/07877 , DPG/M/2006/80167 , DARPG/E/2006/08028 , DARPG/E/
2006/08029 , DARPG/E/2006/08032 , DARPG/E/2006/08043 , DARPG/E/
2006/08044 , DPG/M/2006/80174 , DPG/M/2006/80193 , DARPG/E/
2007/00044 , DPG/M/2007/80003 , DPG/M/2007/80010 , DARPG/E/
2007/00164 , DARPG/E/2007/00165 , DPG/M/2007/80014 , DPG/M/
2007/80025 , DPG/M/2007/80049 , DPG/M/2007/80055 , DPG/M/2007/80056 ,
DPG/M/2007/80078 , DPG/M/2007/80082 , DARPG/E/2007/02618
Q124. the appeals made to the honourable supreme court of India ,
copies of which are available at following web pages :
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/naghrw/message/182
,
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/naghrw/message/206
,
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/naghrw/message/208
,
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/naghrw/message/212
,
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/naghrw/message/209
,
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/naghrw
what are the status of those appeals ?
Q125. in the media , we have seen re****ts about judges committing
crimes - rape , attempt to murder , swindling government money ,
untouchability practice , the disrespect to national flag , sale of
judicial orders , bail , etc. by this way , judges themselves are
making contempt of court , constitution of India & citizens of India.
How you are protecting the honour of the judiciary , constitution of
India & citizens of India ? please answer.
Q126. Is the government giving any facilities / affirmative actions to
policemen's family as being given to defense personnel , ex-servicemen
& their families , like preferential site allotment , lpg agency ,
ration depot , reservation in college admission , soft bank loans ,
etc ?
Q126. if not , why ? after all , the contribution of police to
national security is on par with defense forces.
Q127. is not some high police officials addressing their subordinates
in singular term , abusing them with vulgar words wrong ?
Q128. is not some police personnel calling public with singular term,
abusing public with vulgar words wrong ?
Q129. is it not the duty of prison authorities to protect the health,
lives of prison in-mates ?
Q130.what action is taken against police personnel who wrongly charged
an innocent person of criminal acts , resulting in his confinement in
jail , finally acquitted by court as found to be innocent ?
Q131. is it not right to with hold salary , gratuity , pension to such
guilty police personnel & pay it as compensation to victims of police
failures & atrocities ?
Q132. does our Indian constitution legally permit a citizen of foreign
origin naturalized by marriage to an Indian or naturalized by
option , to occupy any constitutional office ? ( new addition )
Q133. during british rule in india & various other british colonies ,
criminal cases were foisted against our freedom fighters in India &
other british colonies. After india's independence what happened to
those cases ? did our Indian government close all such cases or did it
continue with the prosecution ? ( new addition )
Q134. in how many cases GOI & other state government continued with
the prosecution AGAINST OUR FREEDOM FIGHTERS ? why ? ( new addition )
Q135. what about cases against shri.netaji subash Chandra bose ? ( new
addition )
Q136. has GOI de****ted any freedom fighters to Britain or it's
colonies , to face prosecution after India gained independence ? HAS
GOI RECEIVED ANY REQUEST FROM BRITAIN TO THAT EFFECT ? if yes , why ,
whom ? ( new addition )
Q137. some of the police officers drink alchoholic drinks while on
duty , how do you ensure the rightness of their actions when they are
drunk ? ( NEW ADDITION )
Q138. some of the arrested persons are produced by police at odd
hours , in the residences of judicial magistrates . if the magistrate
has taken alchoholic drinks after office hours , how the rightness of
his decision can be ensured ? ( NEW ADDITION )
<script type="text/javascript">
var irr_lang = 'en';
</script>
<script src="http://fragments.irrepressible.info/js/fragment-125.js"
type="text/javascript">
</script>
Edited, printed , published owned by NAGARAJ.M.R. @[EMAIL PROTECTED]
#LIG-2 / 761,HUDCO
FIRST STAGE ,OPP WATER WORKS , LAXMIKANTANAGAR , HEBBAL ,MYSORE ..........
570017 INDIA........................cell :09341820313
home page : http://groups.yahoo.com/group/naghrw,
http://groups.google.co.in/group/hrwepaper/,
http://evoiceofhumanrightswatch.wordpress.com/
,
http://indiapolicelaw.blogspot.com/
, http://hrwpaper.blogspot.com/
, http://naghrw.tripod.com/evoice/
,
http://e-voiceofhumanrightswatch.blogspot.com,
contact : naghrw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
, nagarajhrw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
member of AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL INDIA
|
