Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Culture > UK Language Culture English > Re: Books readi...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 22 of 34 Topic 809 of 944
Post > Topic >>

Re: Books reading recommendation request

by "Richard Maurer" <rcpb1_maurer@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Aug 4, 2007 at 07:13 AM

Peter Moylan wrote:
    When I first read Catch-22, probably about 40 years ago,
    I ranked it as one of the best books I'd ever read.
    The film of the book was also good. (And from me,
    that's high praise. Usually I hate films based on books
    I've liked.) About two years ago I read the book again,
    and that time I found it pretty good, but not really
    laugh-inducing. Perhaps you had to read it in the right era.


A factor in making the era right was that there was nothing
like it in the decade before, just hundreds of stories about
heroic efforts [1].  Afterwards there were hundreds of books
and movies treating the dark comedy insanities of war and 
bad leader****p.  When the book came out all that was
a big surprise, which helps in the inducing of laughs.
As with many wonderful things, it would be hard for
someone encountering them decades later to appreciate
that pre-nothingness.

It is funny how 90% of the humor in previous eras,
those more than 70 years ago, is not funny anymore.


[1] Although it would not totally surprise me if
someone in aue names some relevant books.

--                       ---------------------------------------------
Richard Maurer              To reply, remove half
Sunnyvale, California       of a homonym of a synonym for also.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
 




 34 Posts in Topic:
Books reading recommendation request
Neil Jones <castellan2  2007-07-29 14:37:59 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"mUs1Ka" <mU  2007-07-29 18:49:06 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"Don Phillipson"  2007-07-29 14:46:49 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Neil Jones <castellan2  2007-07-29 16:02:38 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
the Omrud <usenet.omru  2007-07-30 10:37:38 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"Amethyst Deceiver&q  2007-07-30 11:31:56 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
John Hall <nospam_nov0  2007-07-29 21:58:45 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
tony cooper <tony_coop  2007-07-29 14:55:39 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"John Briggs" &  2007-07-29 20:50:11 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"jerry_friedman@[EMA  2007-07-29 12:32:15 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Neil Jones <castellan2  2007-07-29 16:04:43 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Ben Shimmin <bas@[EMAI  2007-07-29 21:35:06 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Robin Bignall <docrobi  2007-07-29 22:35:11 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Robert Bannister <robb  2007-07-30 08:39:05 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Owain <owain47125@[EMA  2007-07-29 20:32:58 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"jerry_friedman@[EMA  2007-07-29 18:32:30 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Oleg Lego <rat@[EMAIL   2007-07-29 21:37:55 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
tony cooper <tony_coop  2007-07-30 00:22:21 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Oleg Lego <rat@[EMAIL   2007-07-30 13:07:39 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Peter Moylan <peter@[E  2007-07-31 18:56:46 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Oleg Lego <rat@[EMAIL   2007-07-31 08:03:41 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"Richard Maurer"  2007-08-04 07:13:55 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
R H Draney <dadoctah@[  2007-07-30 01:53:29 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
John Ramsay <jramsay@[  2007-07-30 02:33:18 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Blue Sow <janet.read@[  2007-07-30 10:57:35 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Molly Mockford <nospam  2007-07-30 14:25:50 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"Richard R. Hershber  2007-07-30 08:40:12 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Robert Bannister <robb  2007-07-31 07:24:36 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
"jerry_friedman@[EMA  2007-07-30 20:56:54 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Toby A Inkster <usenet  2007-07-31 08:51:14 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Toby A Inkster <usenet  2007-07-31 09:00:44 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
tony cooper <tony_coop  2007-07-31 08:01:11 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Oleg Lego <rat@[EMAIL   2007-07-31 08:00:29 
Re: Books reading recommendation request
Robert Bannister <robb  2007-08-01 09:30:56 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sat Oct 11 23:06:32 CDT 2008.